Feature: Book Genie Mode - Automated Testing with Detailed Reporting
File name: BookGenie.feature
Relative path: features/BookGenie.feature
Scenario Outline: Book Genie Response Validation with Citation Verification
When
I open the Creative Workspace login page
00:00:02.889
Then
I should see the homepage
00:00:00.045
When
I click on the mode selection dropdown
00:00:00.000
Then
I can see the "BookGenieQA" mode
00:00:00.000
And
I select the "BookGenieQA" mode
00:00:00.000
Then
I type "Suggest 5 books on christmas" on chat input element
00:00:03.427
And
I wait for AI to complete thinking
00:00:07.924
And
I validate the response is visible for "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
00:00:00.007
And
I extract book data from BookGenie response
00:00:00.006
And
I save BookGenie book data to Excel file for query "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
00:00:00.000
+ Show Error
Error: No book data extracted from BookGenie response.
at CustomWorld.(anonymous) (/home/runner/work/HC_Epub_Automation/HC_Epub_Automation/tests/steps/bookGenie.step.ts:46:15)
at /home/runner/work/HC_Epub_Automation/HC_Epub_Automation/tests/steps/bookGenie.step.ts:8:71
at __awaiter (/home/runner/work/HC_Epub_Automation/HC_Epub_Automation/tests/steps/bookGenie.step.ts:4:12)
at CustomWorld.(anonymous) (/home/runner/work/HC_Epub_Automation/HC_Epub_Automation/tests/steps/bookGenie.step.ts:59:12)
And
I validate each book individually against Excel file for query "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
0s
And
I validate that reason texts match citation texts with 80% similarity
0s
And
I generate detailed citation validation report
0s
Then
I verify database connectivity
0s
And
database should contain 2020 books
0s
And
I validate extracted books individually against database
0s
And
I validate BookGenie response relevance with AI for query "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
0s
=== SCENARIO LOGS: Book Genie Response Validation with Citation Verification === [12:21:39 PM] Navigating to Creative Workspace login page [12:21:42 PM] Homepage visibility: false [12:21:42 PM] ℹ️ Typing query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas" [12:21:42 PM] ℹ️ Preparing to type query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas" [12:21:42 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for chat input to be visible [12:21:44 PM] ℹ️ Clearing chat input [12:21:44 PM] ℹ️ Typing query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas" [12:21:45 PM] ℹ️ Pressing Enter to submit query [12:21:45 PM] ✅ Query submitted successfully: "Suggest 5 books on christmas" [12:21:45 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for AI to complete thinking... [12:21:45 PM] 📋 WAITING FOR AI RESPONSE [12:21:45 PM] ℹ️ Looking for AI thinking indicator... [12:21:45 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for thinking indicator to appear (max 2 minutes) [12:21:47 PM] ✅ ✓ AI thinking indicator appeared - AI is processing the request [12:21:47 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for thinking indicator to disappear (max 5 minutes) [12:21:50 PM] ✅ ✓ AI thinking completed - Response should be ready [12:21:50 PM] ℹ️ Allowing additional time for response rendering [12:21:53 PM] ✅ AI response wait process completed [12:21:53 PM] ℹ️ Validating response for query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas" [12:21:53 PM] 📋 VALIDATING RESPONSE FOR QUERY: "Suggest 5 books on christmas" [12:21:53 PM] ℹ️ Locating the latest response in chat [12:21:53 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for response to be visible (max 30 seconds) [12:21:53 PM] ✅ Response received - Length: 608 characters [12:21:53 PM] ℹ️ Response preview: Watch Me WorkInterpreting context for your query...That sounds like a lovely theme! To help you find... [12:21:53 PM] ℹ️ Extracting book data from response... [12:21:53 PM] 📋 EXTRACTING BOOK DATA FROM RESPONSE [12:21:53 PM] ℹ️ Locating BookGenie response container [12:21:53 PM] ℹ️ Extracting HTML content from response [12:21:53 PM] ℹ️ HTML content extracted - Length: 7160 characters [12:21:53 PM] ℹ️ Parsing HTML to extract book data [12:21:53 PM] ✅ SUCCESSFULLY EXTRACTED 0 BOOKS [12:21:53 PM] 📋 EXTRACTED BOOKS SUMMARY [12:21:53 PM] 📊 Total books extracted: 0 [12:21:53 PM] 📊 Average relevance score: 0% [12:21:53 PM] ✅ Extracted 0 books from response === END LOGS ===
Scenario Logs: Book Genie Response Validation with Citation Verification
[12:21:39 PM] Navigating to Creative Workspace login page
[12:21:42 PM] Homepage visibility: false
[12:21:42 PM] ℹ️ Typing query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[12:21:42 PM] ℹ️ Preparing to type query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[12:21:42 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for chat input to be visible
[12:21:44 PM] ℹ️ Clearing chat input
[12:21:44 PM] ℹ️ Typing query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[12:21:45 PM] ℹ️ Pressing Enter to submit query
[12:21:45 PM] ✅ Query submitted successfully: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[12:21:45 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for AI to complete thinking...
[12:21:45 PM] 📋 WAITING FOR AI RESPONSE
[12:21:45 PM] ℹ️ Looking for AI thinking indicator...
[12:21:45 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for thinking indicator to appear (max 2 minutes)
[12:21:47 PM] ✅ ✓ AI thinking indicator appeared - AI is processing the request
[12:21:47 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for thinking indicator to disappear (max 5 minutes)
[12:21:50 PM] ✅ ✓ AI thinking completed - Response should be ready
[12:21:50 PM] ℹ️ Allowing additional time for response rendering
[12:21:53 PM] ✅ AI response wait process completed
[12:21:53 PM] ℹ️ Validating response for query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[12:21:53 PM] 📋 VALIDATING RESPONSE FOR QUERY: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[12:21:53 PM] ℹ️ Locating the latest response in chat
[12:21:53 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for response to be visible (max 30 seconds)
[12:21:53 PM] ✅ Response received - Length: 608 characters
[12:21:53 PM] ℹ️ Response preview: Watch Me WorkInterpreting context for your query...That sounds like a lovely theme! To help you find...
[12:21:53 PM] ℹ️ Extracting book data from response...
[12:21:53 PM] 📋 EXTRACTING BOOK DATA FROM RESPONSE
[12:21:53 PM] ℹ️ Locating BookGenie response container
[12:21:53 PM] ℹ️ Extracting HTML content from response
[12:21:53 PM] ℹ️ HTML content extracted - Length: 7160 characters
[12:21:53 PM] ℹ️ Parsing HTML to extract book data
[12:21:53 PM] ✅ SUCCESSFULLY EXTRACTED 0 BOOKS
[12:21:53 PM] 📋 EXTRACTED BOOKS SUMMARY
[12:21:53 PM] 📊 Total books extracted: 0
[12:21:53 PM] 📊 Average relevance score: 0%
[12:21:53 PM] ✅ Extracted 0 books from response
Scenario Outline: Book Genie Response Validation with Citation Verification
When
I open the Creative Workspace login page
00:00:02.568
Then
I should see the homepage
00:00:00.032
When
I click on the mode selection dropdown
00:00:00.000
Then
I can see the "BookGenieQA" mode
00:00:00.000
And
I select the "BookGenieQA" mode
00:00:00.000
Then
I type "Suggest 3 books for childrens" on chat input element
00:00:03.179
And
I wait for AI to complete thinking
00:00:15.616
And
I validate the response is visible for "Suggest 3 books for childrens"
00:00:00.007
And
I extract book data from BookGenie response
00:00:00.008
And
I save BookGenie book data to Excel file for query "Suggest 3 books for childrens"
00:00:00.009
And
I validate each book individually against Excel file for query "Suggest 3 books for childrens"
00:00:00.013
CITATION VALIDATION DETAILED REPORT ================================================================================ BOOK: Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped ------------------------------------------------------------ ✅ Reason 1: PASS (100%) ✅ Reason 2: PASS (100%) ✅ Reason 3: PASS (100%) ❌ Reason 4: FAIL (0%) 📝 Reason: The book is a chapter book suitable for kids ages 6-10... 📚 Citation: chapter books for kids ages 6-10... ⚠️ Citation text not found in reason: "chapter books for kids ages 6-10" BOOK: A Christmas Carol ------------------------------------------------------------ ❌ Reason 1: FAIL (0%) 📝 Reason: The book is a classic... 📚 Citation: classic literature... ⚠️ Citation text not found in reason: "classic literature" ❌ Reason 2: FAIL (0%) 📝 Reason: The book falls under the genre of JUVENILE FICTION... 📚 Citation: JUVENILE FICTION: Classics... ⚠️ Citation text not found in reason: "JUVENILE FICTION: Classics" ❌ Reason 3: FAIL (0%) 📝 Reason: The book is appropriate for children with an interest age from 6 to 10... 📚 Citation: Interest age, years: from 6 to 10... ⚠️ Citation text not found in reason: "Interest age, years: from 6 to 10" BOOK: A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning ------------------------------------------------------------ ✅ Reason 1: PASS (100%) ✅ Reason 2: PASS (100%) ❌ Reason 3: FAIL (0%) 📝 Reason: The book is appropriate for children with an interest age from 8 to 12... 📚 Citation: Interest age, years: from 8 to 12... ⚠️ Citation text not found in reason: "Interest age, years: from 8 to 12" SUMMARY: 5/10 reasons passed (50.0%) OVERALL STATUS: FAIL
Citation validation failed: 5/10 passed (50.0%)
Citation Validation Summary: 5/10 passed
📊 Citation Validation Report
Generated on 10/9/2025, 12:23:34 PM
📖 Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped
✅ Reason 1: 100% match
✅ Reason 2: 100% match
✅ Reason 3: 100% match
❌ Reason 4: 0% match
⚠️ Citation text not found in reason: "chapter books for kids ages 6-10"
📖 A Christmas Carol
❌ Reason 1: 0% match
⚠️ Citation text not found in reason: "classic literature"
❌ Reason 2: 0% match
⚠️ Citation text not found in reason: "JUVENILE FICTION: Classics"
❌ Reason 3: 0% match
⚠️ Citation text not found in reason: "Interest age, years: from 6 to 10"
📖 A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning
✅ Reason 1: 100% match
✅ Reason 2: 100% match
❌ Reason 3: 0% match
⚠️ Citation text not found in reason: "Interest age, years: from 8 to 12"
📈 Validation Summary
Total Reasons Validated: 10
Passed: 5
Failed: 5
Pass Rate: 50.0%
Overall Status: FAIL
Then
I verify database connectivity
00:00:00.167
And
database should contain 2020 books
00:00:00.099
And
I validate extracted books individually against database
00:00:00.236
And
I validate BookGenie response relevance with AI for query "Suggest 3 books for childrens"
00:01:02.759
+ Show Info
+ Show Info
PER-BOOK AI VALIDATION REPORT - Query: "Suggest 3 books for childrens" ================================================================================ OVERALL RELEVANCE SCORE: 93% STATUS: PASS BOOKS ANALYZED: 3 BOOK 1: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" ------------------------------------------------------------ Overall Score: 95% SECTION SCORES: Author Information: 95% - Author is correctly identified and useful context is provided by mentioning another popular series. Publishing Date: 90% - The date is accurate for the edition. While not a recent release, it's perfectly relevant for a children's book series. Why Match Explanations: 95% - Excellent justifications. The inclusion of genre, series information, author credibility, and a specific age range (6-10) is extremely helpful for the broad query. Relevance Scores: 95% - The provided score of 100% is well-justified as the book is a perfect fit for the query. The high score is appropriate. DETAILED FEEDBACK: • This is a strong, highly relevant recommendation for a broad 'children's books' query. • The 'Why Match' section is particularly effective because it provides a specific age range, which greatly helps the user. IMPROVEMENT SUGGESTIONS: • To be even more complete, the author section could clarify Jimmy Pickering's role as the illustrator. ================================================================================ BOOK 2: "A Christmas Carol" ------------------------------------------------------------ Overall Score: 90% SECTION SCORES: Author Information: 90% - The author is correctly identified. While Charles Dickens is famous, a small note on his significance could add value. Publishing Date: 85% - The date is for a modern children's edition, which is relevant, but it's potentially misleading without mentioning the original 1843 publication date. Why Match Explanations: 90% - The reasons are strong, correctly identifying it as a classic, its genre for this edition, and the target age range (6-10), which is crucial for this particular book. Relevance Scores: 90% - The 100% score is defensible as it's a classic for children, but the original text's language can be challenging. Specifying this edition makes it a very strong match. DETAILED FEEDBACK: • A good recommendation of a classic book, made relevant by specifying an edition and age range suitable for children. • The lack of context for the publishing date is the main weakness. IMPROVEMENT SUGGESTIONS: • The publishing date information should be contextualized by stating it's for a specific edition and also providing the original publication year (1843). ================================================================================ BOOK 3: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" ------------------------------------------------------------ Overall Score: 95% SECTION SCORES: Author Information: 95% - Correctly identifies the well-known author Lemony Snicket. The name itself carries significant weight in children's literature. Publishing Date: 85% - The date provided (2009) is for a re-release. It would be more comprehensive to also include the original 1999 publication date for context. Why Match Explanations: 95% - The justifications are excellent, highlighting that it's the start of a popular series, its genre, and a specific age range, making it a very clear recommendation. Relevance Scores: 95% - The provided 100% score is highly justified as this is an iconic and beloved modern children's series, making it an ideal match for the query. DETAILED FEEDBACK: • An excellent and highly relevant choice that aligns perfectly with the query for a children's book. • The reasoning is clear, concise, and provides all the necessary information for a user to make a decision. IMPROVEMENT SUGGESTIONS: • Improve the publishing date information by including the original publication year (1999) for better historical context. ================================================================================ SUMMARY FEEDBACK: ---------------------------------------- • The response provided three high-quality, relevant, and varied book suggestions for the general query. • The 'Why Match' explanations are a major strength, especially when they include specific target age ranges, which adds significant value to a broad query. OVERALL IMPROVEMENT SUGGESTIONS: ---------------------------------------- • The main area for improvement is the handling of publishing dates. For re-releases of older books, providing both the edition's date and the original publication date would be more accurate and informative. • Consistently adding a brief, relevant fact about the author could enhance the author information section across all recommendations.
🤖 PER-BOOK AI Response Relevance Validation
Query: "Suggest 3 books for childrens"
Overall Relevance Score: 93%
Status: PASS
Books Analyzed: 3
Individual Book Analyses
📖 Book 1: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" - 95%
Author Information: 95%
Author is correctly identified and useful context is provided by mentioning another popular series.
Publishing Date: 90%
The date is accurate for the edition. While not a recent release, it's perfectly relevant for a children's book series.
Why Match Explanations: 95%
Excellent justifications. The inclusion of genre, series information, author credibility, and a specific age range (6-10) is extremely helpful for the broad query.
Relevance Scores: 95%
The provided score of 100% is well-justified as the book is a perfect fit for the query. The high score is appropriate.
Improvement Suggestions:
💡 To be even more complete, the author section could clarify Jimmy Pickering's role as the illustrator.
📖 Book 2: "A Christmas Carol" - 90%
Author Information: 90%
The author is correctly identified. While Charles Dickens is famous, a small note on his significance could add value.
Publishing Date: 85%
The date is for a modern children's edition, which is relevant, but it's potentially misleading without mentioning the original 1843 publication date.
Why Match Explanations: 90%
The reasons are strong, correctly identifying it as a classic, its genre for this edition, and the target age range (6-10), which is crucial for this particular book.
Relevance Scores: 90%
The 100% score is defensible as it's a classic for children, but the original text's language can be challenging. Specifying this edition makes it a very strong match.
Improvement Suggestions:
💡 The publishing date information should be contextualized by stating it's for a specific edition and also providing the original publication year (1843).
📖 Book 3: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" - 95%
Author Information: 95%
Correctly identifies the well-known author Lemony Snicket. The name itself carries significant weight in children's literature.
Publishing Date: 85%
The date provided (2009) is for a re-release. It would be more comprehensive to also include the original 1999 publication date for context.
Why Match Explanations: 95%
The justifications are excellent, highlighting that it's the start of a popular series, its genre, and a specific age range, making it a very clear recommendation.
Relevance Scores: 95%
The provided 100% score is highly justified as this is an iconic and beloved modern children's series, making it an ideal match for the query.
Improvement Suggestions:
💡 Improve the publishing date information by including the original publication year (1999) for better historical context.
Summary Feedback
• The response provided three high-quality, relevant, and varied book suggestions for the general query.
• The 'Why Match' explanations are a major strength, especially when they include specific target age ranges, which adds significant value to a broad query.
Overall Improvement Suggestions
💡 The main area for improvement is the handling of publishing dates. For re-releases of older books, providing both the edition's date and the original publication date would be more accurate and informative.
💡 Consistently adding a brief, relevant fact about the author could enhance the author information section across all recommendations.
=== SCENARIO LOGS: Book Genie Response Validation with Citation Verification === [12:21:55 PM] Navigating to Creative Workspace login page [12:21:58 PM] Homepage visibility: false [12:21:58 PM] ℹ️ Typing query: "Suggest 3 books for childrens" [12:21:58 PM] ℹ️ Preparing to type query: "Suggest 3 books for childrens" [12:21:58 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for chat input to be visible [12:21:59 PM] ℹ️ Clearing chat input [12:21:59 PM] ℹ️ Typing query: "Suggest 3 books for childrens" [12:22:00 PM] ℹ️ Pressing Enter to submit query [12:22:01 PM] ✅ Query submitted successfully: "Suggest 3 books for childrens" [12:22:01 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for AI to complete thinking... [12:22:01 PM] 📋 WAITING FOR AI RESPONSE [12:22:01 PM] ℹ️ Looking for AI thinking indicator... [12:22:01 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for thinking indicator to appear (max 2 minutes) [12:22:03 PM] ✅ ✓ AI thinking indicator appeared - AI is processing the request [12:22:03 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for thinking indicator to disappear (max 5 minutes) [12:22:13 PM] ✅ ✓ AI thinking completed - Response should be ready [12:22:13 PM] ℹ️ Allowing additional time for response rendering [12:22:16 PM] ✅ AI response wait process completed [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Validating response for query: "Suggest 3 books for childrens" [12:22:16 PM] 📋 VALIDATING RESPONSE FOR QUERY: "Suggest 3 books for childrens" [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Locating the latest response in chat [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for response to be visible (max 30 seconds) [12:22:16 PM] ✅ Response received - Length: 2180 characters [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Response preview: Watch Me WorkInterpreting context for your query...Retrieving Relevant Books for 'books suitable for... [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Extracting book data from response... [12:22:16 PM] 📋 EXTRACTING BOOK DATA FROM RESPONSE [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Locating BookGenie response container [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Extracting HTML content from response [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ HTML content extracted - Length: 26706 characters [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Parsing HTML to extract book data [12:22:16 PM] ✅ SUCCESSFULLY EXTRACTED 3 BOOKS [12:22:16 PM] 📋 EXTRACTED BOOKS SUMMARY [12:22:16 PM] 📚 1. "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" - Score: 100%% [12:22:16 PM] 📚 2. "A Christmas Carol" - Score: 100%% [12:22:16 PM] 📚 3. "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" - Score: 100%% [12:22:16 PM] 📊 Total books extracted: 3 [12:22:16 PM] 📊 Average relevance score: 100% [12:22:16 PM] ✅ Extracted 3 books from response [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Saving 3 books to Excel file: test_results/suggest_3_books_for_childrens.xlsx [12:22:16 PM] 📋 SAVING BOOKS TO EXCEL FILE [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Target file path: test_results/suggest_3_books_for_childrens.xlsx [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Exporting 3 books to Excel format [12:22:16 PM] ✅ Book data saved to: test_results/suggest_3_books_for_childrens.xlsx [12:22:16 PM] 📊 File verified - Size: 16.97 KB [12:22:16 PM] ✅ ✓ Excel file creation verified successfully [12:22:16 PM] 📋 STARTING INDIVIDUAL BOOK VALIDATION (3 books) for query: "Suggest 3 books for childrens" [12:22:16 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 1: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" vs expected: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" [12:22:16 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 100% vs expected: 100% [12:22:16 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 100% (expected 100%) [12:22:16 PM] ✅ ✅ PERFECT SCORE GAP VALIDATION: Book has 100% score and no gap mentioned [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 4 vs expected 4 [12:22:16 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 4 points (expected 4) [12:22:16 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 1 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED! [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Book 1 validation completed [12:22:16 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 2: "A Christmas Carol" [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "A Christmas Carol" vs expected: "A Christmas Carol" [12:22:16 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "A Christmas Carol" [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 100% vs expected: 100% [12:22:16 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 100% (expected 100%) [12:22:16 PM] ✅ ✅ PERFECT SCORE GAP VALIDATION: Book has 100% score and no gap mentioned [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 3 vs expected 3 [12:22:16 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 3 points (expected 3) [12:22:16 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 2 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED! [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Book 2 validation completed [12:22:16 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 3: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" vs expected: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" [12:22:16 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 100% vs expected: 100% [12:22:16 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 100% (expected 100%) [12:22:16 PM] ✅ ✅ PERFECT SCORE GAP VALIDATION: Book has 100% score and no gap mentioned [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 3 vs expected 3 [12:22:16 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 3 points (expected 3) [12:22:16 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 3 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED! [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Book 3 validation completed [12:22:16 PM] 📊 VALIDATION SUMMARY: 3/3 books passed [12:22:16 PM] ✅ ALL BOOKS VALIDATED SUCCESSFULLY! [12:22:16 PM] 📋 🔍 VALIDATING REASON-CITATION MATCHES [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Starting citation validation process... [12:22:16 PM] 📋 🚀 STARTING COMPLETE CITATION VALIDATION WORKFLOW [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Step 1: Extracting books from AI response [12:22:16 PM] 📋 EXTRACTING BOOK DATA FROM RESPONSE [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Locating BookGenie response container [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Extracting HTML content from response [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ HTML content extracted - Length: 26706 characters [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Parsing HTML to extract book data [12:22:16 PM] ✅ SUCCESSFULLY EXTRACTED 3 BOOKS [12:22:16 PM] 📋 EXTRACTED BOOKS SUMMARY [12:22:16 PM] 📚 1. "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" - Score: 100%% [12:22:16 PM] 📚 2. "A Christmas Carol" - Score: 100%% [12:22:16 PM] 📚 3. "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" - Score: 100%% [12:22:16 PM] 📊 Total books extracted: 3 [12:22:16 PM] 📊 Average relevance score: 100% [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Step 2: Extracting citation texts from book elements [12:22:16 PM] 📋 📚 EXTRACTING CITATION TEXTS FROM BOOK ELEMENTS [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Step 1: Waiting for main book section [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Found 7 total accordion sections [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "1. Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" [12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "2. A Christmas Carol" [12:22:17 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "3. A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" [12:22:17 PM] ℹ️ Processing 3 individual book sections [12:22:17 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 1: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" [12:22:17 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" [12:22:20 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" [12:22:20 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" [12:22:23 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" [12:22:23 PM] ℹ️ Found 4 citation buttons for "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" [12:22:23 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 1/4 for "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" [12:22:23 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 1 for "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" [12:22:24 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 1 [12:22:26 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): Araminta Spookie... [12:22:26 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 1 [12:22:27 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 1 closed successfully [12:22:27 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 1 extracted successfully (length: 16) [12:22:27 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 2/4 for "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" [12:22:27 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 2 for "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" [12:22:28 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 2 [12:22:30 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): JUVENILE FICTION... [12:22:30 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 2 [12:22:32 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 2 closed successfully [12:22:32 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 2 extracted successfully (length: 16) [12:22:32 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 3/4 for "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" [12:22:32 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 3 for "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" [12:22:33 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 3 [12:22:35 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): ANGIE SAGE, the celebrated author of the Septimus Heap series... [12:22:35 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 3 [12:22:37 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 3 closed successfully [12:22:37 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 3 extracted successfully (length: 61) [12:22:37 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 4/4 for "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" [12:22:37 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 4 for "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" [12:22:38 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 4 [12:22:40 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): chapter books for kids ages 6-10... [12:22:40 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 4 [12:22:41 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 4 closed successfully [12:22:41 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 4 extracted successfully (length: 32) [12:22:41 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" [12:22:43 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" [12:22:43 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" - 4 citations extracted [12:22:43 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 2: "A Christmas Carol" [12:22:43 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "A Christmas Carol" [12:22:46 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "A Christmas Carol" [12:22:46 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "A Christmas Carol" [12:22:49 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "A Christmas Carol" [12:22:49 PM] ℹ️ Found 3 citation buttons for "A Christmas Carol" [12:22:49 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 1/3 for "A Christmas Carol" [12:22:49 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 1 for "A Christmas Carol" [12:22:50 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 1 [12:22:52 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): classic literature... [12:22:52 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 1 [12:22:54 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 1 closed successfully [12:22:54 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 1 extracted successfully (length: 18) [12:22:54 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 2/3 for "A Christmas Carol" [12:22:54 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 2 for "A Christmas Carol" [12:22:55 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 2 [12:22:57 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): JUVENILE FICTION: Classics... [12:22:57 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 2 [12:22:58 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 2 closed successfully [12:22:58 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 2 extracted successfully (length: 26) [12:22:58 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 3/3 for "A Christmas Carol" [12:22:58 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 3 for "A Christmas Carol" [12:22:59 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 3 [12:23:01 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): Interest age, years: from 6 to 10... [12:23:01 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 3 [12:23:03 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 3 closed successfully [12:23:03 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 3 extracted successfully (length: 33) [12:23:03 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "A Christmas Carol" [12:23:04 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "A Christmas Carol" [12:23:04 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "A Christmas Carol" - 3 citations extracted [12:23:04 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 3: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" [12:23:04 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" [12:23:07 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" [12:23:07 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" [12:23:10 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" [12:23:10 PM] ℹ️ Found 3 citation buttons for "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" [12:23:10 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 1/3 for "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" [12:23:10 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 1 for "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" [12:23:11 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 1 [12:23:14 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): A Series of Unfortunate Events... [12:23:14 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 1 [12:23:15 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 1 closed successfully [12:23:15 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 1 extracted successfully (length: 30) [12:23:15 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 2/3 for "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" [12:23:15 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 2 for "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" [12:23:16 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 2 [12:23:18 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): JUVENILE FICTION... [12:23:18 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 2 [12:23:20 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 2 closed successfully [12:23:20 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 2 extracted successfully (length: 16) [12:23:20 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 3/3 for "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" [12:23:20 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 3 for "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" [12:23:21 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 3 [12:23:23 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): Interest age, years: from 8 to 12... [12:23:23 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 3 [12:23:24 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 3 closed successfully [12:23:24 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 3 extracted successfully (length: 33) [12:23:24 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" [12:23:26 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" [12:23:26 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" - 3 citations extracted [12:23:26 PM] ✅ 🎉 Successfully extracted citations from 3 books [12:23:26 PM] ℹ️ Step 3: Validating reason-citation matches [12:23:26 PM] 📋 🔍 VALIDATING REASON-CITATION MATCHES (80% THRESHOLD) [12:23:26 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 4 reasons for: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" [12:23:26 PM] ℹ️ Reason 1: Checking match... [12:23:26 PM] ✅ ✅ "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" - Reason 1: 100% match - PASS [12:23:26 PM] ℹ️ Reason 2: Checking match... [12:23:26 PM] ✅ ✅ "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" - Reason 2: 100% match - PASS [12:23:26 PM] ℹ️ Reason 3: Checking match... [12:23:26 PM] ✅ ✅ "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" - Reason 3: 100% match - PASS [12:23:26 PM] ℹ️ Reason 4: Checking match... [12:23:29 PM] ❌ ❌ "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" - Reason 4: 0% match - FAIL [12:23:29 PM] ❌ ⚠️ Citation text not found in reason: "chapter books for kids ages 6-10" [12:23:29 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 3 reasons for: "A Christmas Carol" [12:23:29 PM] ℹ️ Reason 1: Checking match... [12:23:30 PM] ❌ ❌ "A Christmas Carol" - Reason 1: 0% match - FAIL [12:23:30 PM] ❌ ⚠️ Citation text not found in reason: "classic literature" [12:23:30 PM] ℹ️ Reason 2: Checking match... [12:23:34 PM] ❌ ❌ "A Christmas Carol" - Reason 2: 0% match - FAIL [12:23:34 PM] ❌ ⚠️ Citation text not found in reason: "JUVENILE FICTION: Classics" [12:23:34 PM] ℹ️ Reason 3: Checking match... [12:23:34 PM] ❌ ❌ "A Christmas Carol" - Reason 3: 0% match - FAIL [12:23:34 PM] ❌ ⚠️ Citation text not found in reason: "Interest age, years: from 6 to 10" [12:23:34 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 3 reasons for: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" [12:23:34 PM] ℹ️ Reason 1: Checking match... [12:23:34 PM] ✅ ✅ "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" - Reason 1: 100% match - PASS [12:23:34 PM] ℹ️ Reason 2: Checking match... [12:23:34 PM] ✅ ✅ "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" - Reason 2: 100% match - PASS [12:23:34 PM] ℹ️ Reason 3: Checking match... [12:23:34 PM] ❌ ❌ "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" - Reason 3: 0% match - FAIL [12:23:34 PM] ❌ ⚠️ Citation text not found in reason: "Interest age, years: from 8 to 12" [12:23:34 PM] 📊 📊 CITATION VALIDATION SUMMARY: 5/10 passed (50.0%) [12:23:34 PM] ❌ 💥 REASON-CITATION VALIDATION: OVERALL FAILED [12:23:34 PM] ℹ️ Step 4: Generating detailed report [12:23:34 PM] 📋 📋 GENERATING CITATION VALIDATION REPORT [12:23:34 PM] ℹ️ Report generated: 5/10 reasons passed [12:23:34 PM] ✅ ✅ Citation validation workflow completed successfully [12:23:34 PM] 📊 📈 OVERALL CITATION VALIDATION: 5/10 (50.0%) [12:23:34 PM] ❌ ❌ REASON-CITATION VALIDATION: OVERALL FAILED - Only 50.0% of reasons match citations (required: 80%) [12:23:34 PM] 📋 📋 GENERATING DETAILED CITATION VALIDATION REPORT [12:23:34 PM] ℹ️ Generating HTML citation validation report [12:23:34 PM] ✅ Generated HTML report for 10 reasons [12:23:34 PM] ✅ ✅ Citation validation HTML report generated and attached [12:23:34 PM] ✅ ✅ Citation validation plain text report attached [12:23:34 PM] ℹ️ Checking database connectivity... [12:23:35 PM] ✅ ✅ Database connected successfully [12:23:35 PM] ℹ️ Database path: /home/runner/work/HC_Epub_Automation/HC_Epub_Automation/tests/test_data/database.xlsx [12:23:35 PM] ℹ️ Total books: 5455 [12:23:35 PM] 📊 Database contains 5455 books [12:23:35 PM] ✅ ✅ Database book count requirement met: 5455 >= 2020 [12:23:35 PM] 📋 🔍 VALIDATING EXTRACTED BOOKS INDIVIDUALLY AGAINST DATABASE [12:23:35 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 1/3: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" [12:23:35 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" [12:23:35 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" → "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" [12:23:35 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 2/3: "A Christmas Carol" [12:23:35 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "A Christmas Carol" [12:23:35 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "A Christmas Carol" → "A Christmas Carol" [12:23:35 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 3/3: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" [12:23:35 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" [12:23:35 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" → "He" [12:23:35 PM] 📊 INDIVIDUAL DATABASE VALIDATION SUMMARY: 3/3 books found in database [12:23:35 PM] ✅ 🎉 ALL BOOKS VALIDATED SUCCESSFULLY AGAINST DATABASE! [12:23:35 PM] 📋 🤖 VALIDATING RESPONSE RELEVANCE WITH GEMINI AI - PER BOOK ANALYSIS [12:23:35 PM] ℹ️ Starting Gemini AI per-book relevance validation... [12:23:35 PM] 📋 🤖 ANALYZING RESPONSE RELEVANCE WITH GEMINI AI - PER BOOK ANALYSIS [12:23:35 PM] ℹ️ Starting Gemini AI analysis with retry logic... [12:24:38 PM] 📊 Gemini AI Overall Relevance Score: 93% [12:24:38 PM] 📊 Analyzed 3 books individually [12:24:38 PM] ✅ ✅ GEMINI VALIDATION: Response is relevant to query (93%) [12:24:38 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" - Score: 95% [12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Author Information: 95% - Author is correctly identified and useful context is provided by mentioning another popular series. [12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Publishing Date: 90% - The date is accurate for the edition. While not a recent release, it's perfectly relevant for a children's book series. [12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Why Match Explanations: 95% - Excellent justifications. The inclusion of genre, series information, author credibility, and a specific age range (6-10) is extremely helpful for the broad query. [12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Relevance Scores: 95% - The provided score of 100% is well-justified as the book is a perfect fit for the query. The high score is appropriate. [12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements: [12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ - To be even more complete, the author section could clarify Jimmy Pickering's role as the illustrator. [12:24:38 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "A Christmas Carol" - Score: 90% [12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Author Information: 90% - The author is correctly identified. While Charles Dickens is famous, a small note on his significance could add value. [12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Publishing Date: 85% - The date is for a modern children's edition, which is relevant, but it's potentially misleading without mentioning the original 1843 publication date. [12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Why Match Explanations: 90% - The reasons are strong, correctly identifying it as a classic, its genre for this edition, and the target age range (6-10), which is crucial for this particular book. [12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Relevance Scores: 90% - The 100% score is defensible as it's a classic for children, but the original text's language can be challenging. Specifying this edition makes it a very strong match. [12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements: [12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ - The publishing date information should be contextualized by stating it's for a specific edition and also providing the original publication year (1843). [12:24:38 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" - Score: 95% [12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Author Information: 95% - Correctly identifies the well-known author Lemony Snicket. The name itself carries significant weight in children's literature. [12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Publishing Date: 85% - The date provided (2009) is for a re-release. It would be more comprehensive to also include the original 1999 publication date for context. [12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Why Match Explanations: 95% - The justifications are excellent, highlighting that it's the start of a popular series, its genre, and a specific age range, making it a very clear recommendation. [12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Relevance Scores: 95% - The provided 100% score is highly justified as this is an iconic and beloved modern children's series, making it an ideal match for the query. [12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements: [12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ - Improve the publishing date information by including the original publication year (1999) for better historical context. [12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ 📊 SUMMARY FEEDBACK: [12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ • The response provided three high-quality, relevant, and varied book suggestions for the general query. [12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ • The 'Why Match' explanations are a major strength, especially when they include specific target age ranges, which adds significant value to a broad query. [12:24:38 PM] ✅ ✅ GEMINI AI VALIDATION PASSED: 93% relevance score === END LOGS ===
Scenario Logs: Book Genie Response Validation with Citation Verification
[12:21:55 PM] Navigating to Creative Workspace login page
[12:21:58 PM] Homepage visibility: false
[12:21:58 PM] ℹ️ Typing query: "Suggest 3 books for childrens"
[12:21:58 PM] ℹ️ Preparing to type query: "Suggest 3 books for childrens"
[12:21:58 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for chat input to be visible
[12:21:59 PM] ℹ️ Clearing chat input
[12:21:59 PM] ℹ️ Typing query: "Suggest 3 books for childrens"
[12:22:00 PM] ℹ️ Pressing Enter to submit query
[12:22:01 PM] ✅ Query submitted successfully: "Suggest 3 books for childrens"
[12:22:01 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for AI to complete thinking...
[12:22:01 PM] 📋 WAITING FOR AI RESPONSE
[12:22:01 PM] ℹ️ Looking for AI thinking indicator...
[12:22:01 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for thinking indicator to appear (max 2 minutes)
[12:22:03 PM] ✅ ✓ AI thinking indicator appeared - AI is processing the request
[12:22:03 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for thinking indicator to disappear (max 5 minutes)
[12:22:13 PM] ✅ ✓ AI thinking completed - Response should be ready
[12:22:13 PM] ℹ️ Allowing additional time for response rendering
[12:22:16 PM] ✅ AI response wait process completed
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Validating response for query: "Suggest 3 books for childrens"
[12:22:16 PM] 📋 VALIDATING RESPONSE FOR QUERY: "Suggest 3 books for childrens"
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Locating the latest response in chat
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for response to be visible (max 30 seconds)
[12:22:16 PM] ✅ Response received - Length: 2180 characters
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Response preview: Watch Me WorkInterpreting context for your query...Retrieving Relevant Books for 'books suitable for...
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Extracting book data from response...
[12:22:16 PM] 📋 EXTRACTING BOOK DATA FROM RESPONSE
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Locating BookGenie response container
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Extracting HTML content from response
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ HTML content extracted - Length: 26706 characters
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Parsing HTML to extract book data
[12:22:16 PM] ✅ SUCCESSFULLY EXTRACTED 3 BOOKS
[12:22:16 PM] 📋 EXTRACTED BOOKS SUMMARY
[12:22:16 PM] 📚 1. "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" - Score: 100%%
[12:22:16 PM] 📚 2. "A Christmas Carol" - Score: 100%%
[12:22:16 PM] 📚 3. "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" - Score: 100%%
[12:22:16 PM] 📊 Total books extracted: 3
[12:22:16 PM] 📊 Average relevance score: 100%
[12:22:16 PM] ✅ Extracted 3 books from response
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Saving 3 books to Excel file: test_results/suggest_3_books_for_childrens.xlsx
[12:22:16 PM] 📋 SAVING BOOKS TO EXCEL FILE
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Target file path: test_results/suggest_3_books_for_childrens.xlsx
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Exporting 3 books to Excel format
[12:22:16 PM] ✅ Book data saved to: test_results/suggest_3_books_for_childrens.xlsx
[12:22:16 PM] 📊 File verified - Size: 16.97 KB
[12:22:16 PM] ✅ ✓ Excel file creation verified successfully
[12:22:16 PM] 📋 STARTING INDIVIDUAL BOOK VALIDATION (3 books) for query: "Suggest 3 books for childrens"
[12:22:16 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 1: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped"
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" vs expected: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped"
[12:22:16 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped"
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 100% vs expected: 100%
[12:22:16 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 100% (expected 100%)
[12:22:16 PM] ✅ ✅ PERFECT SCORE GAP VALIDATION: Book has 100% score and no gap mentioned
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 4 vs expected 4
[12:22:16 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 4 points (expected 4)
[12:22:16 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 1 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED!
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Book 1 validation completed
[12:22:16 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 2: "A Christmas Carol"
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "A Christmas Carol" vs expected: "A Christmas Carol"
[12:22:16 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "A Christmas Carol"
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 100% vs expected: 100%
[12:22:16 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 100% (expected 100%)
[12:22:16 PM] ✅ ✅ PERFECT SCORE GAP VALIDATION: Book has 100% score and no gap mentioned
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 3 vs expected 3
[12:22:16 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 3 points (expected 3)
[12:22:16 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 2 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED!
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Book 2 validation completed
[12:22:16 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 3: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" vs expected: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[12:22:16 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 100% vs expected: 100%
[12:22:16 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 100% (expected 100%)
[12:22:16 PM] ✅ ✅ PERFECT SCORE GAP VALIDATION: Book has 100% score and no gap mentioned
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 3 vs expected 3
[12:22:16 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 3 points (expected 3)
[12:22:16 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 3 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED!
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Book 3 validation completed
[12:22:16 PM] 📊 VALIDATION SUMMARY: 3/3 books passed
[12:22:16 PM] ✅ ALL BOOKS VALIDATED SUCCESSFULLY!
[12:22:16 PM] 📋 🔍 VALIDATING REASON-CITATION MATCHES
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Starting citation validation process...
[12:22:16 PM] 📋 🚀 STARTING COMPLETE CITATION VALIDATION WORKFLOW
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Step 1: Extracting books from AI response
[12:22:16 PM] 📋 EXTRACTING BOOK DATA FROM RESPONSE
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Locating BookGenie response container
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Extracting HTML content from response
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ HTML content extracted - Length: 26706 characters
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Parsing HTML to extract book data
[12:22:16 PM] ✅ SUCCESSFULLY EXTRACTED 3 BOOKS
[12:22:16 PM] 📋 EXTRACTED BOOKS SUMMARY
[12:22:16 PM] 📚 1. "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" - Score: 100%%
[12:22:16 PM] 📚 2. "A Christmas Carol" - Score: 100%%
[12:22:16 PM] 📚 3. "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" - Score: 100%%
[12:22:16 PM] 📊 Total books extracted: 3
[12:22:16 PM] 📊 Average relevance score: 100%
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Step 2: Extracting citation texts from book elements
[12:22:16 PM] 📋 📚 EXTRACTING CITATION TEXTS FROM BOOK ELEMENTS
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Step 1: Waiting for main book section
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Found 7 total accordion sections
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "1. Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped"
[12:22:16 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "2. A Christmas Carol"
[12:22:17 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "3. A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[12:22:17 PM] ℹ️ Processing 3 individual book sections
[12:22:17 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 1: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped"
[12:22:17 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped"
[12:22:20 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped"
[12:22:20 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped"
[12:22:23 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped"
[12:22:23 PM] ℹ️ Found 4 citation buttons for "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped"
[12:22:23 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 1/4 for "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped"
[12:22:23 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 1 for "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped"
[12:22:24 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 1
[12:22:26 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): Araminta Spookie...
[12:22:26 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 1
[12:22:27 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 1 closed successfully
[12:22:27 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 1 extracted successfully (length: 16)
[12:22:27 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 2/4 for "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped"
[12:22:27 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 2 for "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped"
[12:22:28 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 2
[12:22:30 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): JUVENILE FICTION...
[12:22:30 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 2
[12:22:32 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 2 closed successfully
[12:22:32 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 2 extracted successfully (length: 16)
[12:22:32 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 3/4 for "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped"
[12:22:32 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 3 for "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped"
[12:22:33 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 3
[12:22:35 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): ANGIE SAGE, the celebrated author of the Septimus Heap series...
[12:22:35 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 3
[12:22:37 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 3 closed successfully
[12:22:37 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 3 extracted successfully (length: 61)
[12:22:37 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 4/4 for "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped"
[12:22:37 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 4 for "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped"
[12:22:38 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 4
[12:22:40 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): chapter books for kids ages 6-10...
[12:22:40 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 4
[12:22:41 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 4 closed successfully
[12:22:41 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 4 extracted successfully (length: 32)
[12:22:41 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped"
[12:22:43 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped"
[12:22:43 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" - 4 citations extracted
[12:22:43 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 2: "A Christmas Carol"
[12:22:43 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "A Christmas Carol"
[12:22:46 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "A Christmas Carol"
[12:22:46 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "A Christmas Carol"
[12:22:49 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "A Christmas Carol"
[12:22:49 PM] ℹ️ Found 3 citation buttons for "A Christmas Carol"
[12:22:49 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 1/3 for "A Christmas Carol"
[12:22:49 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 1 for "A Christmas Carol"
[12:22:50 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 1
[12:22:52 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): classic literature...
[12:22:52 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 1
[12:22:54 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 1 closed successfully
[12:22:54 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 1 extracted successfully (length: 18)
[12:22:54 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 2/3 for "A Christmas Carol"
[12:22:54 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 2 for "A Christmas Carol"
[12:22:55 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 2
[12:22:57 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): JUVENILE FICTION: Classics...
[12:22:57 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 2
[12:22:58 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 2 closed successfully
[12:22:58 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 2 extracted successfully (length: 26)
[12:22:58 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 3/3 for "A Christmas Carol"
[12:22:58 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 3 for "A Christmas Carol"
[12:22:59 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 3
[12:23:01 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): Interest age, years: from 6 to 10...
[12:23:01 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 3
[12:23:03 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 3 closed successfully
[12:23:03 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 3 extracted successfully (length: 33)
[12:23:03 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "A Christmas Carol"
[12:23:04 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "A Christmas Carol"
[12:23:04 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "A Christmas Carol" - 3 citations extracted
[12:23:04 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 3: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[12:23:04 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[12:23:07 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[12:23:07 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[12:23:10 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[12:23:10 PM] ℹ️ Found 3 citation buttons for "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[12:23:10 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 1/3 for "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[12:23:10 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 1 for "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[12:23:11 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 1
[12:23:14 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): A Series of Unfortunate Events...
[12:23:14 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 1
[12:23:15 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 1 closed successfully
[12:23:15 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 1 extracted successfully (length: 30)
[12:23:15 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 2/3 for "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[12:23:15 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 2 for "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[12:23:16 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 2
[12:23:18 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): JUVENILE FICTION...
[12:23:18 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 2
[12:23:20 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 2 closed successfully
[12:23:20 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 2 extracted successfully (length: 16)
[12:23:20 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 3/3 for "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[12:23:20 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 3 for "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[12:23:21 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 3
[12:23:23 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): Interest age, years: from 8 to 12...
[12:23:23 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 3
[12:23:24 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 3 closed successfully
[12:23:24 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 3 extracted successfully (length: 33)
[12:23:24 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[12:23:26 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[12:23:26 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" - 3 citations extracted
[12:23:26 PM] ✅ 🎉 Successfully extracted citations from 3 books
[12:23:26 PM] ℹ️ Step 3: Validating reason-citation matches
[12:23:26 PM] 📋 🔍 VALIDATING REASON-CITATION MATCHES (80% THRESHOLD)
[12:23:26 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 4 reasons for: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped"
[12:23:26 PM] ℹ️ Reason 1: Checking match...
[12:23:26 PM] ✅ ✅ "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" - Reason 1: 100% match - PASS
[12:23:26 PM] ℹ️ Reason 2: Checking match...
[12:23:26 PM] ✅ ✅ "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" - Reason 2: 100% match - PASS
[12:23:26 PM] ℹ️ Reason 3: Checking match...
[12:23:26 PM] ✅ ✅ "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" - Reason 3: 100% match - PASS
[12:23:26 PM] ℹ️ Reason 4: Checking match...
[12:23:29 PM] ❌ ❌ "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" - Reason 4: 0% match - FAIL
[12:23:29 PM] ❌ ⚠️ Citation text not found in reason: "chapter books for kids ages 6-10"
[12:23:29 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 3 reasons for: "A Christmas Carol"
[12:23:29 PM] ℹ️ Reason 1: Checking match...
[12:23:30 PM] ❌ ❌ "A Christmas Carol" - Reason 1: 0% match - FAIL
[12:23:30 PM] ❌ ⚠️ Citation text not found in reason: "classic literature"
[12:23:30 PM] ℹ️ Reason 2: Checking match...
[12:23:34 PM] ❌ ❌ "A Christmas Carol" - Reason 2: 0% match - FAIL
[12:23:34 PM] ❌ ⚠️ Citation text not found in reason: "JUVENILE FICTION: Classics"
[12:23:34 PM] ℹ️ Reason 3: Checking match...
[12:23:34 PM] ❌ ❌ "A Christmas Carol" - Reason 3: 0% match - FAIL
[12:23:34 PM] ❌ ⚠️ Citation text not found in reason: "Interest age, years: from 6 to 10"
[12:23:34 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 3 reasons for: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[12:23:34 PM] ℹ️ Reason 1: Checking match...
[12:23:34 PM] ✅ ✅ "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" - Reason 1: 100% match - PASS
[12:23:34 PM] ℹ️ Reason 2: Checking match...
[12:23:34 PM] ✅ ✅ "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" - Reason 2: 100% match - PASS
[12:23:34 PM] ℹ️ Reason 3: Checking match...
[12:23:34 PM] ❌ ❌ "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" - Reason 3: 0% match - FAIL
[12:23:34 PM] ❌ ⚠️ Citation text not found in reason: "Interest age, years: from 8 to 12"
[12:23:34 PM] 📊 📊 CITATION VALIDATION SUMMARY: 5/10 passed (50.0%)
[12:23:34 PM] ❌ 💥 REASON-CITATION VALIDATION: OVERALL FAILED
[12:23:34 PM] ℹ️ Step 4: Generating detailed report
[12:23:34 PM] 📋 📋 GENERATING CITATION VALIDATION REPORT
[12:23:34 PM] ℹ️ Report generated: 5/10 reasons passed
[12:23:34 PM] ✅ ✅ Citation validation workflow completed successfully
[12:23:34 PM] 📊 📈 OVERALL CITATION VALIDATION: 5/10 (50.0%)
[12:23:34 PM] ❌ ❌ REASON-CITATION VALIDATION: OVERALL FAILED - Only 50.0% of reasons match citations (required: 80%)
[12:23:34 PM] 📋 📋 GENERATING DETAILED CITATION VALIDATION REPORT
[12:23:34 PM] ℹ️ Generating HTML citation validation report
[12:23:34 PM] ✅ Generated HTML report for 10 reasons
[12:23:34 PM] ✅ ✅ Citation validation HTML report generated and attached
[12:23:34 PM] ✅ ✅ Citation validation plain text report attached
[12:23:34 PM] ℹ️ Checking database connectivity...
[12:23:35 PM] ✅ ✅ Database connected successfully
[12:23:35 PM] ℹ️ Database path: /home/runner/work/HC_Epub_Automation/HC_Epub_Automation/tests/test_data/database.xlsx
[12:23:35 PM] ℹ️ Total books: 5455
[12:23:35 PM] 📊 Database contains 5455 books
[12:23:35 PM] ✅ ✅ Database book count requirement met: 5455 >= 2020
[12:23:35 PM] 📋 🔍 VALIDATING EXTRACTED BOOKS INDIVIDUALLY AGAINST DATABASE
[12:23:35 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 1/3: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped"
[12:23:35 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped"
[12:23:35 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" → "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped"
[12:23:35 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 2/3: "A Christmas Carol"
[12:23:35 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "A Christmas Carol"
[12:23:35 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "A Christmas Carol" → "A Christmas Carol"
[12:23:35 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 3/3: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[12:23:35 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[12:23:35 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" → "He"
[12:23:35 PM] 📊 INDIVIDUAL DATABASE VALIDATION SUMMARY: 3/3 books found in database
[12:23:35 PM] ✅ 🎉 ALL BOOKS VALIDATED SUCCESSFULLY AGAINST DATABASE!
[12:23:35 PM] 📋 🤖 VALIDATING RESPONSE RELEVANCE WITH GEMINI AI - PER BOOK ANALYSIS
[12:23:35 PM] ℹ️ Starting Gemini AI per-book relevance validation...
[12:23:35 PM] 📋 🤖 ANALYZING RESPONSE RELEVANCE WITH GEMINI AI - PER BOOK ANALYSIS
[12:23:35 PM] ℹ️ Starting Gemini AI analysis with retry logic...
[12:24:38 PM] 📊 Gemini AI Overall Relevance Score: 93%
[12:24:38 PM] 📊 Analyzed 3 books individually
[12:24:38 PM] ✅ ✅ GEMINI VALIDATION: Response is relevant to query (93%)
[12:24:38 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "Araminta Spookie 3: Frognapped" - Score: 95%
[12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Author Information: 95% - Author is correctly identified and useful context is provided by mentioning another popular series.
[12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Publishing Date: 90% - The date is accurate for the edition. While not a recent release, it's perfectly relevant for a children's book series.
[12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Why Match Explanations: 95% - Excellent justifications. The inclusion of genre, series information, author credibility, and a specific age range (6-10) is extremely helpful for the broad query.
[12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Relevance Scores: 95% - The provided score of 100% is well-justified as the book is a perfect fit for the query. The high score is appropriate.
[12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements:
[12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ - To be even more complete, the author section could clarify Jimmy Pickering's role as the illustrator.
[12:24:38 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "A Christmas Carol" - Score: 90%
[12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Author Information: 90% - The author is correctly identified. While Charles Dickens is famous, a small note on his significance could add value.
[12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Publishing Date: 85% - The date is for a modern children's edition, which is relevant, but it's potentially misleading without mentioning the original 1843 publication date.
[12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Why Match Explanations: 90% - The reasons are strong, correctly identifying it as a classic, its genre for this edition, and the target age range (6-10), which is crucial for this particular book.
[12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Relevance Scores: 90% - The 100% score is defensible as it's a classic for children, but the original text's language can be challenging. Specifying this edition makes it a very strong match.
[12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements:
[12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ - The publishing date information should be contextualized by stating it's for a specific edition and also providing the original publication year (1843).
[12:24:38 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" - Score: 95%
[12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Author Information: 95% - Correctly identifies the well-known author Lemony Snicket. The name itself carries significant weight in children's literature.
[12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Publishing Date: 85% - The date provided (2009) is for a re-release. It would be more comprehensive to also include the original 1999 publication date for context.
[12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Why Match Explanations: 95% - The justifications are excellent, highlighting that it's the start of a popular series, its genre, and a specific age range, making it a very clear recommendation.
[12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Relevance Scores: 95% - The provided 100% score is highly justified as this is an iconic and beloved modern children's series, making it an ideal match for the query.
[12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements:
[12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ - Improve the publishing date information by including the original publication year (1999) for better historical context.
[12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ 📊 SUMMARY FEEDBACK:
[12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ • The response provided three high-quality, relevant, and varied book suggestions for the general query.
[12:24:38 PM] ℹ️ • The 'Why Match' explanations are a major strength, especially when they include specific target age ranges, which adds significant value to a broad query.
[12:24:38 PM] ✅ ✅ GEMINI AI VALIDATION PASSED: 93% relevance score